If you paid $500 brand new then you paid way too much. Got the one for my 2011 (which I know is a different model #) for $200 new seven years ago. You can buy a brand new one for less on several different websites.
leadersrpmshop.com

Victory New OEM Motorcycle Chrome Tachometer Gauge Kit, Cross Roads, 2877652
Brand new, genuine Victory Motorcycle Chrome Tachometer Gauge Kit, Cross Roads. This is a factory original equipment accessory, not aftermarket.